Wednesday, October 01, 2008

Why are we in a mess??

The other day I was thinking why are we in a mess in India? May be the beginning was not so good? May be the starting point was not well conceived? Of course I am not saying that the great personalities of that time did any blunder. I am sure given those conditions, they have done the best thing. Still these are my personal views, dreams rather...

  • First of all, constitution of the republic was almost the same as that of the colonial India. Hence, we never had a new start.
  • Those officers and police who were serving the Britishers till independence retained their job. So, those who were killing and oppressing the freedom fighters and who were philosophically against the idea of independent India, were suddenly given the right to rule independent India. They should in fact have been treated as prisoners of war and properly tried. And under no circumstances they should have been allowed to retain the power. So basically we drove the foreigners but kept the instruments of foreign rule.
  • Next, we forced the complete British India into a single republic. It was made a federation, but the states had little power. Neither was there any proper common thread for unity nor was there sufficient independence for diversity.
  • Hence, it was neither like Europe not like America. People may oppose this view of mine. But, we we see it objectively without prejudice, I don't see any reason for including unwilling princely states forcibly. Gandhi's idea of local governance was completely sabotaged!

The list goes on. We never had a real independence. We never got that confident outlook that an independent sovereign state should have. And at the same time the short-cuts we took actually has put us in long-cuts... I dont see any solution though!!!

2 comments:

Unknown said...

Hi!
Nice read but was just wondering... what's 'real independence' ? Where is man free?


Anyways, when we cannot think of 'solutions' perhaps it's better not to look at things as 'problems', but just circumstances that we can't refuse facing. Hopefully, these 'long cuts' could just mean some detour.........

Mister Mangu said...

Yes you are right. But we have to agree that life is a constant persuit towards betterment in layman's terms! Higher souls may say philosophical thing though! Hence, we got to find problems and then solutions. Finding the right problem is as good as half solving it! So this is just the status quo... I found some problems. Once I know I have a problem then only I can thikn of a solution.

As far as independence is concerned, man is free no where... agreed. But then why were Indians fighting against Brits?